Skip to main content

Review And Comparison: Otterbox Commuter And Defender Cases For The Galaxy Nexus


Cases - some people love them, others hate them. Regardless of how you feel about them, there is one truth: they're useful and help keep your device in top condition. A quick look through eBay or Craigslist will prove the value of keeping your gear in a case - when trying to sell a device most users put "has been in a case since day one" or something similar (whether it's true or not). That assures the buyer that they are getting a near-mint condition piece of kit.
When it comes to top-notch device protection, one name often comes to mind: Otterbox. They make some of the toughest, longest lasting, and most protective cases that we've ever seen. Today we're going to take a look at two cases designed for the Galaxy Nexus: the Commuter and Defender series.
wm_IMG_20120123_095255 wm_IMG_20120123_095405

Commuter

Price: $35.99 ($25 at Amazon)
Where to Buy: OtterboxAmazon
In the Box: Case, Screen protector
The Bottom Line: This is the most practical solution for the average user. It provides enough protection to keep your device in good condition under most circumstances while still leaving access to all of the necessary functions. While it does add a bit of bulk to the device (don't all cases?) it's worth the trade-off for the added peace of mind.
wm_IMG_20120123_095108 wm_IMG_20120123_095126
Note: Ignore the metal ring around the lens, this is not part of the case - it's for add-on camera lenses.

The Good

  • Two layers of protection - The Commuter is a two-part case: a soft silicone under-layer for shock absorption and a hard  polycarbonate outer shell.
  • Provides a full-protection solution - Between the two-part case and the included screen protector, your device is protected from end-to-end, front-to-back.
  • Port coverage - The silicon layer has small flaps that cover all of the I/O ports like the microUSB port and headphone jack, keeping them both free of debris.
  • Great fit - You can rest assured that your Galaxy Nexus will be as snug as a bug in a rug whilst in this case. It's a perfect fit.
  • Smart design - When you drop your phone, where does it normally land? On the corners. With this in mind, the polycarbonate shell cuts away from the corners of the device, leaving the rubbery silicone to take, and absorb, the hit. That's just smart.

The Bad

  • The back is slick - Oddly enough, the back of the case is quick slick, which could lead to more drops. Fortunately, if you do drop it, it's in a case.
  • Power and Volume buttons are slightly hard to press - When pressing the power/volume keys, you don't actually feel the button move. You know you pressed it, but the case doesn't give enough to provide a tangible reaction. It takes some getting used to, but after a while, it's not so bad.
  • It's difficult to put on - The silicone layer goes on very easily, but the hard shell is a bit difficult to manage at first. It gets easier as time goes on, I promise.
  • The silicone is slightly tacky - This one is pretty minor, but it's a con nonetheless. The silicone has a certain stickiness to it, so it's somewhat difficult to take out of your pocket (and lint sticks to it).
  • It adds some bulk - Let's face it - any case with substance is going to add some bulk, and it takes away from the beauty and elegance of the device itself. It's the price we pay for protection.
wm_IMG_20120123_095214
Like stated above, this is definitely the most practical solution for the average Joe. It's just rugged enough to protect your device during day-to-day activities, provides full device protection when you use the included screen protector, and even protects the phone's ports from dirt and grime.
Despite its few downsides, this is a great case. If, however, you tend to be a little more rough on devices (like my dad, for example - he completely destroyed three phones with cases in one year), then you should probably read on and check out the Defender.

Defender

Price: $49.95 (currently $33 at Amazon)
Where to Buy: OtterboxAmazon
In the Box: Two-part case, belt clip holster
The Bottom Line: If you're known for killing devices in an instant and need supercharged protection for your GN, this is the case for you. It provides thorough protection of the device, has a built-in screen protector, and feelsgreat in-hand.
wm_IMG_20120123_095427 wm_IMG_20120123_095421
wm_IMG_20120123_095637 wm_IMG_20120123_095644
Note: Ignore the metal ring around the lens, this is not part of the case - it's for add-on camera lenses.

The Good

  • Two layers of protection - The Defender uses the same components of the Commuter, but it flips them. Instead of having a soft under-layer and hard shell, you have a hard polycarbonate inner-layer wrapped in a soft, shock-absorbing silicone. And it feels fantastic.
  • Port coverage - Like the commuter, it has silicon flaps to protect the ports. I think this case may provide easier access to said ports than the Commuter, as well.
  • Belt-clip holster - First off, I'm not one to wear my phone on my side, but since this case adds quite a bit of bulk to the device (more on that later), it's pretty uncomfortable in your pocket. Thus, Otterbox includes a holster with it. It's well made, tough-as-nails, and provides the perfect fit for the case.
  • It feels great - I've already mentioned this twice, but it definitely needs to be highlighted as it's probably my favorite feature of this case. The silicone outer shell is soft and smooth, yet it doesn't feel slippery at all. The power and volume buttons are quite tangible through the shell - it's simply a pleasure to use.
  • Built-in screen protector - This one is actually a double-edged sword. On one hand, you don't have to bother trying to apply an on-device screen protector or make sure it's on just right and free of bubbles - the whole tedious process is just eliminated. Just snap it on and you're GN is protected from scratches and other potential damages. On the other hand, it's diminishes the screen quality. More on that below.

The Bad

  • It's pretty dang big - I mentioned the added bulk earlier, and that's definitely the biggest drawback of this case. While it may not look that much thicker than the Commuter in pictures, you can definitely feel it in-hand. Every millimeter makes a bigger difference than you may realize.
  • Built-in screen protector - The downside of the screen protector is that it reduces how beautiful the GN's screen is. Whites don't look quite right, colors don't pop like they do when the device is out of the case. The worst part is that the screen protector can't be removed - it's built-in to the case and not going anywhere.
  • The silicone is slightly tacky - Like the Commuter, the silicone tends to stick inside your pocket (if you choose not to use the holster).
wm_IMG_20120123_095516 wm_IMG_20120123_095653 wm_IMG_20120123_095709
Honestly, it's hard to find things "wrong" with the Defender case. It's well made, feels great, and provides outstanding coverage. Its main downside is a big one (pun intended): the size. That much protection comes at a cost, and in this case it's the cost of device form factor. If you need the extra protection, though, this case is definitely the way to go.

Conclusion

So, which case should you buy? That really depends. Both are very good solutions, but I feel like most people would get all the protection that they need from the Commuter, as long as you can deal with the negative aspects that I mentioned above. If not, the Defender is also a solid choice, and the must-have case for those who are prone to sporadically destroying devices. At the end of the day, it's all each person's individual needs.
For what it's worth, the Commuter stays on my GN about 90% of the time.

Buy

Otterbox Commuter for the Galaxy NexusOtterboxAmazon
Otterbox Defender  for the Galaxy NexusOtterboxAmazon

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ipad apps: AppStart Review

AppStart For iPad Review Free for a limited time only , AppStart for iPad is a terrific app by the folks over at  AppAdvice.com  that’s meant to serve as a starter guide for new iPad users and owners. The promotion is only available for a limited time as customers flock to pick up their iPad 2s this week. Whether you’ve had your iPad since launch day or you just picked one up, AppStart For iPad is a detailed and comprehensive guide for the most popular and useful ways to utilize your iPad in addition to recommending a few apps to get your feet wet. When you first open the app, the home screen is displayed in a clean grid of buttons for you to tap-in and find out everything there is to do with the iPad. Each grid-box allows you to open up a mini-guide for how you can use your iPad as an eReader, home theater, radio, nightstand, magazine, or social media hub. Within each mini-guide, the folks over at App-Advice also throw in their suggestions for both free and paid apps that re...

Ipad 2 Accesories

Zagg have done it again and released what we are excited to say is the seasons MUST HAVE iPad accessory: The  ZAGGmate iPad case with keyboard . It’s not often that we get entirely blown away by an accessory for the iPad, but this one has left us shell shocked and in awe. The perfect compliment to your iPad, this is the first iPad keyboard case combo that we have seen yet that has done it right. In fact, it’s the best bluetooth keyboard we’ve seen to date as well! It’s so right and so perfect that we already wonder how we ever used our iPad without it! Check out the review below… ZAGGmate with Keyboard The iPad’s New Best Friend Our first impression of the ZAGGmate was: “Where’s the rest of it?” This iPad case is unlike anything else we’ve seen on the market to date and the designers at Zagg worked hard to literally rethink what an iPad case could be. This is an iPad case that doesn’t cover the whole iPad, but rather just covers the iPad’s screen, and leaves the back of the tablet...

Ipad 2 Apps: Skyfire Web browser Review

Ipad 2 Apps: Skyfire Web browser Review Skyfire for the iPad made headlines when it was first released, due to its ability to play Flash videos on a device previously void of this popular technology. Users flocked to the App Store, eager to drop five bucks for the chance to view their favorite clips, shows, and movies on their iPad. Not only did the browser play these videos, but the integrated video compression saved a significant amount of bandwidth for people on a restricted data plan. The initial excitement wore off quickly, though, as complaints were rampant about many sites not playing videos as expected. Since its inception Skyfire has certainly improved in this area, now claiming support for over 200,000 websites containing Flash. The dissenters will always be there as not every Flash video on the Web will be playable, even if the developers at Skype Labs remain diligent. Some of the backlash is warranted to a certain extent. If I paid $4.99 with the intent of viewi...